PDA

View Full Version : HP G6000 Laptop "known problem"



randall
20-01-2010, 06:18 AM
Hi
I will be as brief as I can.
I purhcased a HPG6000 laptop for my son in December 2007, in December 2008 wifi failed. I contacted HP, we were a week oustide the 12 month warranty. They sent me a range of things to try to try and restore the service. In the meantime i did some web research and found that HP have exactly the same problem with units sold in the US and had set up a program to replace or repair. After a month or so of trying HP solutions I told them that I wanted it repaired or replaced. They of course wanted to charge as it was out of the 12 month limit. The arghuing went on for some while. After listening to 5 live I heard about the EU consumer law where goods have been replaced up to two years. I contacted Comet and had to go through the whole esclation process. We are now at the point where they want £30 for a "technician" to look at it, they also want it for 28 days. My sone uses the machine for college work and I aksed for a loaner but they won't help. Looking at the web again an increasing number of people in the UK are having the same problem. I believe that this is a "known" HP problem and I am being caught up in a battle betwene them and Comet. Am I within my rights to go and ask for a replacement. I certainly do not believe I shoudl pay £30 for an "inspection". I did point out that I have worked in the IT industry for 30+ years and do know a little bit about these things. I have asked them for the technical spec that HP have sent their "technician" to check the unit but they won't let me have that. I know I should have gone back to HP sooner but I believed that as I was outside their 12 month warranty the manufacturer would be more likely to help.

enkoda
21-01-2010, 11:19 AM
I see from a reply you've had on another forum that HP in the USA are acknowledging issues but HP UK aren't? I bet the US spec machines have exactly the same components inside them. HP UK are simply trying to fob you off and hope you give up.

The only other advice I can suggest is to pursue the line that goods should have a reasonable life expectancy (check the SoGA, I'm positive it's in there somewhere), e.g. televisions are expected to work for at least 6 years, and for the unit to cease providing full functionality so soon after the warranty period has expired is unacceptable.

I would also collate as many complaints as you can find in order to backup your claim that the laptop was never "fit for purpose" in the first place, especially if this a known fault. Then politley, but very firmly, write to HP and suggest they repair the laptop as a goodwill gesture otherwise you will have no option but to seek legal advice.


Good luck!

system7
21-01-2010, 12:04 PM
There are a number of issues for which HP have done recalls or extended warranty or driver updates including batteries, NVidia 8400M and 8600M graphics issues and the like. But most suppliers nevertheless need to inspect a faulty unit first, and will not supply a spare to tide you over.

I would hope that Comet will do their best to resolve this for you. FWIW, Novatech's policy paraphrases to this:


Our out of warranty inspection / repair service works along these lines:

There is an initial inspection charge of £37 including VAT (this is not paid up front). We inspect the notebook for you and advise on what precisely is wrong and how much it will cost to repair and how long it will take.
If you are happy for us to go ahead and repair the notebook for you we waive the inspection fee (i.e. you do not pay it) and you only pay the cost for repair (after it is complete).
If you decide not to go ahead with the suggested repair then you need to pay the £37 inspection fee.
The turn around time for us to inspection at Novatech can vary depending on the problem(s) being reported, but normally it takes 3 to 5 working days at most. Repair times can vary greatly depending on what needs to be repaired - we advise how long it will take after inspecting the notebook.

We do not inspect and/or repair novatech & PCs that were not purchased from us.

Anyone who has troubles with a PC knows that faults are quite often hard to pin down, and it is dangerous to make assumptions in advance.

Ben
21-01-2010, 12:56 PM
The BBC have been doing a few articles on this type of thing recently on various programmes.

Try seeing if any of their advice / letters can help you out.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/theoneshow/consumer/2009/07/03/sale_of_goods_act_letter_downl.html?page=19

Just out of interest, what is the problem?